Zhejiang Guanyu Stainless Steel Tube Co., Ltd  
  Directory | Useful Tool | Sitemap | Contact US | Home

         

Pressure

Material for Heat Exchanger Tube with Pressure difference








Heat exchanger take heat from one fluid and pass it to a second. The fire-tube array of a steam engine is a heat exchanger, taking heat from the hot combustion gases of the firebox and transmitting it to the water in the boiler. The network of finned tubes in an air conditioner is a heat exchanger, taking heat from the air of the room and dumping it into the working fluid of the conditioner. The radiator in a car performs a similar function. The key element in heat exchanger is the tube wall or membrane which separates the two fluids. It is required to transmit heat and there is frequently a large pressure difference across it.

The Model
First, a little background on heat flow. Heat transfer from one fluid, through a membrane to a second fluid, involves convective transfer from fluid 1 into the tube wall, conduction through the wall, and convection again to transfer it into fluid 2. The heat flux q into the tube wall by convection (in units of W/m2) is described by the heat transfer equation:

Equation (1)

in which h1 is the heat transfer coefficient and DT1 is the temperature drop across the surface from fluid 1 into the wall. Conduction is described by the conduction (or Fourier) equation

Equation (2)

where l is the thermal conductivity of the wall (thickness t) and D T12 is the temperature difference across it.

It is helpful to think of the thermal resistance at surface 1 as 1/h1; that of surface 2 is 1/h2; and that of the wall itself is t/l. Then continuity of heat flux requires that the total resistance 1/U is

Equation (3)

where U is called the 'total heat transfer coefficient '. The heat flux from fluid 1 to fluid 2 is then given by

Equation (4)

where DT is the difference in temperature between the two working fluids. When one of the fluids is a gas, as in an air conditioner, heat transfer at the tube surface contributes most of the resistance; then fins are used to increase the surface area across which heat can be transferred. But when both working fluids are liquid, convective heat transfer is rapid and conduction through the wall dominates the thermal resistance. In this case simple tube elements are used, with their wall as thin as possible to maximise l/t. We will consider the second case: conduction limited heat transfer. Then 1/h1 and 1/h2 are negligible when compared with t/l, and the heat transfer equation becomes

Equation (5)

Consider, now, a heat exchanger with many tubes, each of radius r and wall thickness t with a pressure difference Dp between the inside and outside. Our aim is to select a material to maximise the total heat flow, while safely carrying the pressure difference Dp. The total heat flow is

Equation (6)

where A is the total surface area of tubing.

This is the objective function. The constraint is that the wall thickness must be sufficient to support the pressure difference Dp. This requires that the stress in the wall remain below the elastic limit (yield strength) sel (times a safety factor, which need not be included in this analysis):

Equation (7)

Eliminating t between the last two equations gives

Equation (8)

The heat flow per unit area of tube wall, Q/A, is maximised by maximising the performance index:

Equation (9)

Four further considerations enter the selection. It is essential to choose a material that withstands corrosion in the working fluids, which we take here to be water containing chloride ions (sea water). Cost will naturally be of concern. The maximum service temperature must be adequate and the material should be available as drawn tube.

What are the best materials for making heat exchanger? Or, more specifically, what are the best materials for a conduction-limited exchanger, with substantial pressure difference between the two fluids?

Figure 1 Schematic of a heat exchanger

Design Requirements
Function Heat Exchanger
Objective Maximise heat flow per unit area, or per unit weight
Constraints (a) Support pressure difference Dp
(b) Withstand chloride ions
(c) Operating temperature up to 150°C
(d) Low Cost
Table 1

The Selection

A preliminary selection using the Generic filter is shown in Figures 2-4. The first chart is of elastic limit versus thermal conductivity, to allow us to maximise the value of M1. The second stage shows maximum service temperature plotted as a bar-chart against resistance to sea-water, selecting materials with high temperature resistance and high resistance to corrosion in sea-water. The last stage shows a bar chart of material cost against available forms, selecting cheap materials that are available as sheet or tube.


Figure 2 A Chart of Elastic Limit versus Thermal Conductivity


Figure 3 A Bar-chart of Maximum Service Temperature versus Resistance to Sea-Water Corrosion



Figure 4 Material Cost against Available Forms

The results of this selection are shown in Results Table 1, and they suggest that it may be worth transferring the selection criteria to the coppers database to refine the search for a suitable material.

Results

Material (ranked by M1) Comment
High Conductivity Copper Have the best performance index, but relatively poor corrosion resistance
Brasses Again, relatively poor corrosion resistance
Wrought Martensitic Stainless Steel A good choice, but steel is more dense than copper
Aluminium Bronzes An economical and practical choice

Table 1 The Results of the Selection using the Generic Filter

Material (ranked by M1) Comment
90/10 Aluminium bronze, cold wkd (wrought) The aluminium bronzes are cheap
92/8 Aluminium bronze, hard (wrought)  
93/7 Aluminium bronze, hard (wrought)  
95/5 Aluminium bronze, 1/2 hard (wrought)  
95/5 Aluminium bronze, hard (wrought)  
Nickel iron aluminium bronze, as extruded (wrought) The Nickel iron aluminium bronzes are more corrosion resistant
Nickel iron aluminium bronze, hot wkd (wrought)  

Table 2 The Results of the Selection by expanding the coppers branch

PostScript

Conduction may limit heat flow in theory, but unspeakable things go on inside heat exchangers. Sea water - often one of the working fluids - seethes with biofouling organisms which attach themselves to tube walls and thrive, creating a layer of high thermal resistance and impeding fluid flow, like barnacles on a boat. Some materials are more resistant to biofouling than others; copper-nickel alloys are particularly good, probably because the organisms dislike copper salts, even in very low concentrations. Otherwise the problem must be tackled by adding chemical inhibitors to the fluids, or by scraping - the traditional winter pass-time of boat owners.

It is sometimes important to minimise the weight of heat exchangers. Repeating the calculation to seek materials for the lightest heat exchanger gives, instead of M, the index:

Equation (10)

where r is the density of the materials from which the tubes are made. This is quite a different index - the strength varies to the power 2 because the weight depends on the wall thickness, and from Eqn 7 we know that wall thickness varies as 1/strength.

Of course, all copper alloys have roughly the same density, so there is little point applying this index within the coppers in the database - but if copper alloys were compared with stainless steel tube at the Generic level, then it would be relevant.

Related References:
0. What are the Characteristics of High Quality Steel Pipe Manufacturers?
1. How to Purchase stainless Steel Pipe from China
2. Material for Heat Exchanger Tube with Pressure difference
3. Selection of Stainless Steel and Nickel Alloys
4. Stainless Steel Characteristics and Usage by Steel Grade
5. Selection Stainless Steel from Corrosion Physical Mechanicalg
6. Stainless Steel Relative Cost Data
7. Trade Names Associated With Stainless Steel
8. Costs Of Different Metals Used In Mechanical Engineering
9. What is the low cost superior optimal Heat Exchangers?
10. How to Identify Fake Steel Pipes

Related References:
  • Heat Exchanger
  • U bend Stainless Steel Tube for Heat Exchanger
  • Heat Exchanger Tube
  • Specification/Standards for Heat Exchanger Tubes
  • Finned Tube and Pipe Heat Exchangers
  • Shell Tube and Pipe Heat Exchangers
  • Select Materials for Heat Exchanger Tubes with Substantial Pressure difference
  • The difference between Stainless Steel Tubing and Copper Tubing in Shell and Tube Heat Exchanger
  • Difference in Counter and Parallel Flow Heat Exchanger
  • Aluminum Corrosion Resistance for Cold Plates and Plate-Fin Heat Exchangers
  • Flow arrangement
  • Heat exchangers - Tubes and Pipes Standards
  • Selecting a Heat Exchanger Cooling Liquid
  • Selecting a Heat Exchanger Cooling Air
  • Selecting A Cold Plate Technology
  • Selecting a Cooling System: Ambient Cooling System | Recirculating Chiller | Liquid-to-Liquid Cooling System | Recirculating Chiller or Liquid-to-Liquid Cooling System
  • Selecting A Cold Plate Technology
  • Selecting A Pump
  • Selecting a Recirculating Chiller
  • Selecting A Modular Cooling System
  • Selecting an Liquid-to-Liquid Cooling System
  • How to Boost the Efficiency of Heat Exchanger
  • Comparison of Heat Exchanger Types
  • Parallel and Counter Flow Design
  • Direct contact heat exchanger

  • Types of heat exchangers
    Shell and tube heat exchanger
    Plate Heat Exchanger - Efficiency and Flexibility
    U Tube heat exchanger
    Regenerative heat exchanger
    Adiabatic wheel heat exchanger
    Plate fin heat exchanger
    Fluid heat exchangers
    Phase-change heat exchanger
    Parallel Flow Heat Exchanger
    Counter Flow Heat Exchanger
    Cross Flow Heat Exchanger
    Spiral heat exchangers
    Shell and Coil Heat Exchangers
    Brazed Heat Exchangers - Advantages | Applications | Specifications
    Titanium Heat Exchanger
    Plate and Shell Heat Exchanger - Applications | Specification
    Block Welded Heat Exchanger - Applications | Specification


  • Construction
  • Self cleaning
  • Applications
  • Selection
  • Pre Heater
  • Radiator
  • Air Conditioner Evaporator and Condenser
  • Large Steam System Condensers



  • TubingChina.com All Rights Reserved

    Directory | Standard | Heat | Heat Exchanger | Temperature | Pressure | Corrosion | Hardness | Surface | Properties | Select Stainless Steel | Contact US

    Useful Tools:

    Stainless Steel Weight Calculator
    Metals Weight Calculator
    Nickel Alloy Weight Calculator
    Copper Brass Alloy Weight Calculator
    Copper Brass Alloy Sheet Plate Weight Calculator
    Sheet Plate Weight Calculator
    Hardness Conversion Calculator
    Hardness Conversion Chart
    Rockwell Brinell Vickers Shore Hardness Conversion Chart
    Conversion Calculator
    Length Weight Temperature Volume Pressure Calculater
    Pipe Working Pressure Calculator
    Pressure Conversion Converter
    Round Bar Size Calculator
    Gauge Sizes
    Sheet Metal Gauge
    Pipe Schedule
    Nominal Pipe Size
    ANSI Pipe Chart
    Inch to mm Chart
    Stainless Steel Pipe Sizes
    Stainless Steel Tubing Sizes Chart
    Stainless Steel L H Grade
    Stainless Steel Density
    Conversion of Stainless Steel
    Nickel Alloy Grades Comparison Material Grade Chart Carbon Steel
    Structural Steel Comparison Chart



    Main Products:

    BA Tube | AP Tube
    Condenser Tubes Tubing
    Stainless Steel Reheater Tube Superheater Tubes
    Stainless Steel U bend Tube
    Nickel Alloy U bend Tubes
    Copper Alloy U Bend Tubes
    Heat Exchanger Tube
    Super Duplex Pipe
    Nickel Alloy Tube
    Brass Alloy Tubing
    Copper Nickel Alloys Tubes
    Stainless Steel Hollow Tube
    Stainless Steel Oval Tubing
    Stainless Steel Square Tubing
    Stainless Steel Rectangular Tubing
    Stainless Steel Capillary Tube
    Duplex Stainless Steel Pipe
    Seamless Stainless Steel Tubing
    Corrugated Stainless Steel Tubing
    Stainless Steel Twisted Tube
    Polishing Stainless Steel Tubing
    Stainless Steel Aircraft Tube
    Stainless Steel Hydraulic Tubing
    Stainless Steel Instrumentation Tubing
    Stainless Steel Angle Iron Bar
    Stainless Steel Mechanical Tube
    Bright Annealing Stainless Tube
    Heat resistant Stainless Steel
    Stainless Steel Welded Pipe
    Extruded Serrated Finned Tubes Integral Finned Tubes / Extruded Aluminum Finned Tubes
    Brass Alloys Copper Nickel Alloy Integral Low Finned Tubes
    HFW High Frequency Welded Helical Spiral Serrated Finned Tubes
    Corrosion Resistant Stainless Steel
    Corrosion Resistance Stainless Steel

    Stainless Steel Tubing Pipe

    304 Stainless Steel Pipe
    304L Stainless Steel Pipe
    304H Stainless Steel Pipe
    304/304L Stainless Steel Tubing
    309S Stainless Steel Pipe
    310S Stainless Steel Pipe
    316L Stainless Steel Tubing
    316Ti Stainless Steel Tube
    317L Stainless Steel Pipe
    321 321H Stainless Steel
    347 347H Stainless Steel
    904L N08094 Seamless Tubes
    17-4 PH 630 UNS S17400 Stainless Steel
    253MA S30815 Stainless Steel Tube
    S31254 254 SMO Pipe
    S31803 Stainless Steel
    2205 Duplex Pipe Tubing
    S32101 Stainless Steel
    S32304 Stainless Steel
    2507 Super Duplex Pipe
    S32750 Super Duplex Pipe
    S32760 Super Duplex Steel
    1.4462 Stainless Steel Pipe
    ASTM A213 | ASTM A269
    ASTM A312 | ASTM A511
    ASTM A789 | ASTM A790
    ASTM B161 / ASME SB 161 | ASTM B111
    EN 10216-5
    ASTM A789 ASME SA 789 S31803 S32205 S32101 S32750 S32760 S32304 S31500 S31260 Seamless Tubes
    EN 10216-5 1.4462 1.4362 1.4162 1.4410 1.4501 Seamless Tubes
    Nickel Alloy Tubing:

    UNS N08020 Alloy 20 Tubing
    UNS N02200 Alloy 200 Tube
    UNS N02201 Alloy 201 Pipe
    UNS N04400 Monel 400 Tubing
    N06600 Inconel 600 Tube
    N06601 Inconel 601 Tubing
    N06625 Inconel 625 Tubes
    N08800 Incoloy 800 Tube
    N08810 Incoloy 800H Tube
    N08811 Incoloy 800HT Tubing
    UNS N08825 Incoloy 825 Pipe
    ASTM B622 N10276 C276 Tubing
    ASTM B622 N06022 Hastelloy C-22 Alloy Tubes
    C28000 Brass Seamless Tubes C44300 Brass Seamless Tubes
    C68700 Brass Seamless Tubes
    C70600 Copper Nickel Tubes
    C71500 Copper Nickel Tubes
    DIN 2391 Seamless Precision Steel Tubes
    EN 10305-1 E215 E235 E355 Seamless Precision Steel Tube Tubing Tubes
    DIN 2393 St28 St34.2 St37.2 St44.2 St52.3 Welded Precision Steel Tubes
    EN 10305-2 E195 E235 E355 Welded Cold Drawn Precision Steel Tube